Lozman v. City of Riviera Beach

Filed in February 2025

Owners’ Counsel of America joined the Small Property Owners of San Francisco Institute, KDP II, LLC, and the Franklin Conklin Foundation in filing an Amicus Brief urging the U.S. Supreme Court to review Lozman v. City of Riviera Beach. The groups argued that lower courts have created confusion in applying Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council, 505 U.S. 1003 (1992), by focusing on whether regulated property retains some value rather than whether the owner retains an economically beneficial or productive use of the property. The brief emphasized that the right to make productive use of property is central to ownership.

According to the amici, some lower courts have effectively converted the Lucas standard from one concerned with use into one concerned with value, allowing residual property value or hypothetical uses to defeat a takings claim even when the remaining uses are not economically productive. The brief noted that Lucas pairs the word “use” with “economically beneficial” or “economically productive” thirty-seven times, arguing that those qualifying words were included deliberately and that an analysis stopping at the existence of some remaining use is incomplete.

The amici drew a direct comparison between Lucas, where the property owner could maintain a deck but not a home, and Lozman, who could maintain a dock but not a home. In both cases, the brief argued, the regulation permitted the owner to assemble some planks of wood and sit on them, and nothing more productive than that.

The groups urged the Supreme Court to grant certiorari, overturn the result below, and rationalize the law governing regulatory takings claims under the Fifth Amendment. OCA and the other amici were represented by Michael M. Berger of Manatt, Phelps & Phillips, LLP.

Read the full amicus brief by Michael M. Berger here.

Get the Latest Insights

Subscribe for Blog Updates!

close
email telephone877-367-6963