Home | Oregon Eminent Domain

Oregon's Eminent Domain Laws and Property Rights

Meet OCA's Oregon Attorney

Neil Olsen

Neil Olsen

Neil is an experienced litigator and business advisor. In addition to his well-established eminent domain and real estate litigation practice, he advises the firm’s clients on real estate and business transactions, business and valuation-related litigation, and general business matters.

Neil Olsen

Oregon

4035 Douglas Way, Suite 200
Lake Oswego, OR 97035
Tel: (503) 451-5047
neil@olsenbarton.com | www.olsenbarton.com

As a litigator, Neil serves as both a counselor and an advocate for the firm’s clients. He is experienced in all forms of dispute resolution, from mediation and arbitration to trial and appeal. While he strives to reach smart, business-oriented solutions for the firm’s clients, he also understands that such solutions can sometimes only be reached by trying a case.

As a business advisor, Neil serves as an outside “general counsel” to several of the firm’s clients, helping them navigate business formation and transactional matters, employment matters, contracting, and regulatory compliance. On the real estate and land use side, he helps clients with the acquisition, development, lease and sale of commercial property.

Neil has been recognized by his peers in publications such as Best Lawyers in America and Super Lawyers. Prior to becoming an attorney, he served as a legislative analyst for the Texas House of Representatives.

Eminent Domain and Condemnation

  • Represent property owners whose property is targeted for condemnation by TriMet, ODOT, WSDOT, and other public entities in Oregon and Washington.
  • Represent property owners in eminent domain, regulatory takings, and inverse condemnation proceedings.
  • Regular speaker on public infrastructure projects and protection of property owners’ just compensation and due process rights when faced with takings.
  • Obtained eminent domain jury verdict on behalf of property owner that was six times the amount of TriMet’s original offer, plus an award of the property owner’s attorney fees and costs. This was the only case a property owner took to trial against TriMet on the Portland Milwaukie Light Rail project.
  • Obtained $7,630,279 eminent domain jury verdict and fee and cost award for owner of development property, on an original offer of $1,670,000.
  • Obtained $955,353 eminent domain settlement for owner of industrial property, inclusive of fees and costs, on an original offer of $297,000.
  • Obtained $500,000 eminent domain settlement for owner of commercial property, inclusive of fees and costs, on an original offer of $217,000.
  • See Client Successes in Eminent Domain Cases

Real Estate Litigation

  • Represented owners of retail center in enforcement of of $5,000,000 personal guaranty of anchor-tenant lease.
  • Represented owners of retail center in defense of claims regarding common area maintenance.
  • Represented commercial landlord in securing judgment for breach of lease based upon tenant’s early vacation of property.

Commercial and Employment Litigation

  • Represented creative agency in securing a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction in federal court against its former CEO to secure return of proprietary and confidential electronically stored business information.
  • Represented non-profit corporation in breach of fiduciary duty, conversion, fraud, and civil RICO claims against its former treasurer.
  • Represented regional telecommunications company in prosecution of trade secret, non-disclosure, and non-competition claims against two former employees.

Real Estate and Business Transactions

  • Represent regional real estate developer in acquisition, development, and leasing of real property.
  • Represent regional telecommunications company in real estate contracting matters.
  • Represent regional healthcare provider in corporate, contracting, and real estate matters.
  • Represent national aerospace company in local real estate matters.
  • Represent physician practice in corporate, real estate and employment matters.
  • Represented national wireless communications company in negotiating leases for office and retail space.
  • Represented national communications infrastructure company in negotiating leases for office and technical space.

Land Use

  • Represent property owner in planning efforts for property slated to be brought into urban growth boundary.
  • Represented property owner group in its successful efforts to alter major road-widening project planned for established residential area.
  • Represented property owner in securing land use approval to build a wireless communication facility, including successfully defending the appeal of the planning director’s decision.

Construction

  • Represent golf course company in negotiating design and construction contracts.
  • Represented developer in breach of contract and construction defect claims against general contractor.
  • Counseled numerous contractors, architects and engineers in relation to drafting and interpreting construction and consulting contracts, risk minimization, and regulatory compliance.
  • Represented numerous contractors, subcontractors, architects and engineers in construction lien matters.

Publications and Presentations:

  • Oregon Condemnation Law: Neil Olsen’s Blog on Eminent Domain, Regulatory Takings, Inverse Condemnation and Property Rights Litigation
  • Oregon Property Owners’ Handbook: Eminent Domain and Just Compensation Under Oregon Law
  • Is Close Enough Good Enough? Establishing the Date of Valuation in Direct and Inverse Cases, Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation, ALI-CLE, January 23, 2020
  • Improving Actions Leading Up to the 40-day Offer and Prior to Filing of a Complaint, IRWA Fall Education Event, October 16, 2019
  • The “Three Unities” – Still a Problem? A Discussion of Larger Parcel Issues, Oregon Eminent Domain Conference, The Seminar Group, June 6, 2019
  • Preparing Appraisals for Condemnation Assignments and How to Improve Skills as an Expert Witness, Appraisal Institute – Greater Oregon Chapter, January 20, 2017
  • Overview of the Condemnation Process, 8th Annual Oregon Eminent Domain Conference, The Seminar Group, June 5, 2015
  • Ejectment; Suits to Quiet Title, Chapter 61, Oregon Real Estate Deskbook, June, 2015
  • Collateral Damage from Newberg-Dundee Bypass Project, Daily Journal of Commerce, December 19, 2013
  • Columbia River Crossing Will Impact 200 Properties, Portland Business Journal, November 12, 2012]
  • Portland-Milwaukie Light Rail “Mega Project” Moves Forward, Daily Journal of Commerce, April 26, 2011

Reported Case

  • Tri-County Metropolitan Transportation District of Oregon v. Walnut Hill, LLC, 292 Or. App. 417, 424 P.3d 742 (2018) (eminent domain; TriMet light-rail condemnation; jury verdict for just compensation and attorney fees affirmed).

Notable Oregon Property Rights Cases of OCA Emeritus Member Jill S. Gelineau

U.S. Supreme Court

  • Dolan v. City of Tigard, 512 U.S. 374 (1994), on remand, 319 Or 567, 877 P2d 1201 (1994). Landmark exactions case establishing the “rough proportionality” test for permit conditions. (Represented the Dolan family on remand)

Oregon Supreme Court

  • Hope Presbyterian Church of Rogue River v. Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 352 Or 668, 291 P3d 711 (2012). Dispute over church real property and trust ownership. (Amicus Curiae for the Presbyterian Lay Committee)
  • West Linn Corporate Park, L.L.C. v. City of West Linn, No. S056322 (2010). Certified question on interest owed on just compensation in the condemnation of corporate park property. (Co-counsel with D. Joe Willis)

Oregon Court of Appeals

  • Proctor v. City of Portland, 245 Or App 378, 263 P3d 1099 (2011). Challenge to Portland’s business license tax as applied to real estate broker-agents.
  • Clear Channel Outdoor, Inc. v. City of Portland, 231 Or App 511, 220 P3d 100 (2011). Constitutional challenge to Portland’s sign code regulations.
  • Hammer v. City of Eugene, No. A122564 (2005). (Represented the respondent property owner)

EDUCATION

  • J.D., Lewis & Clark Law School
    • Executive Editor, Lewis & Clark Law Review
    • Judicial Extern to the Honorable Michael W. Mosman, United States District Court for the District of Oregon
    • Business Roundtable Scholar
  • B.A., Government, University of Texas at Austin

BAR ADMISSIONS

  • Oregon
  • Washington
  • U.S. District Court for the District of Oregon

As a litigator, Neil serves as both a counselor and an advocate for the firm’s clients. He is experienced in all forms of dispute resolution, from mediation and arbitration to trial and appeal. While he strives to reach smart, business-oriented solutions for the firm’s clients, he also understands that such solutions can sometimes only be reached by trying a case.

As a business advisor, Neil serves as an outside “general counsel” to several of the firm’s clients, helping them navigate business formation and transactional matters, employment matters, contracting, and regulatory compliance. On the real estate and land use side, he helps clients with the acquisition, development, lease and sale of commercial property.

Neil has been recognized by his peers in publications such as Best Lawyers in America and Super Lawyers. Prior to becoming an attorney, he served as a legislative analyst for the Texas House of Representatives.

Eminent Domain and Condemnation

  • Represent property owners whose property is targeted for condemnation by TriMet, ODOT, WSDOT, and other public entities in Oregon and Washington.
  • Represent property owners in eminent domain, regulatory takings, and inverse condemnation proceedings.
  • Regular speaker on public infrastructure projects and protection of property owners’ just compensation and due process rights when faced with takings.
  • Obtained eminent domain jury verdict on behalf of property owner that was six times the amount of TriMet’s original offer, plus an award of the property owner’s attorney fees and costs. This was the only case a property owner took to trial against TriMet on the Portland Milwaukie Light Rail project.
  • Obtained $7,630,279 eminent domain jury verdict and fee and cost award for owner of development property, on an original offer of $1,670,000.
  • Obtained $955,353 eminent domain settlement for owner of industrial property, inclusive of fees and costs, on an original offer of $297,000.
  • Obtained $500,000 eminent domain settlement for owner of commercial property, inclusive of fees and costs, on an original offer of $217,000.
  • See Client Successes in Eminent Domain Cases

Real Estate Litigation

  • Represented owners of retail center in enforcement of of $5,000,000 personal guaranty of anchor-tenant lease.
  • Represented owners of retail center in defense of claims regarding common area maintenance.
  • Represented commercial landlord in securing judgment for breach of lease based upon tenant’s early vacation of property.

Commercial and Employment Litigation

  • Represented creative agency in securing a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction in federal court against its former CEO to secure return of proprietary and confidential electronically stored business information.
  • Represented non-profit corporation in breach of fiduciary duty, conversion, fraud, and civil RICO claims against its former treasurer.
  • Represented regional telecommunications company in prosecution of trade secret, non-disclosure, and non-competition claims against two former employees.

Real Estate and Business Transactions

  • Represent regional real estate developer in acquisition, development, and leasing of real property.
  • Represent regional telecommunications company in real estate contracting matters.
  • Represent regional healthcare provider in corporate, contracting, and real estate matters.
  • Represent national aerospace company in local real estate matters.
  • Represent physician practice in corporate, real estate and employment matters.
  • Represented national wireless communications company in negotiating leases for office and retail space.
  • Represented national communications infrastructure company in negotiating leases for office and technical space.

Land Use

  • Represent property owner in planning efforts for property slated to be brought into urban growth boundary.
  • Represented property owner group in its successful efforts to alter major road-widening project planned for established residential area.
  • Represented property owner in securing land use approval to build a wireless communication facility, including successfully defending the appeal of the planning director’s decision.

Construction

  • Represent golf course company in negotiating design and construction contracts.
  • Represented developer in breach of contract and construction defect claims against general contractor.
  • Counseled numerous contractors, architects and engineers in relation to drafting and interpreting construction and consulting contracts, risk minimization, and regulatory compliance.
  • Represented numerous contractors, subcontractors, architects and engineers in construction lien matters.

Publications and Presentations:

  • Oregon Condemnation Law: Neil Olsen’s Blog on Eminent Domain, Regulatory Takings, Inverse Condemnation and Property Rights Litigation
  • Oregon Property Owners’ Handbook: Eminent Domain and Just Compensation Under Oregon Law
  • Is Close Enough Good Enough? Establishing the Date of Valuation in Direct and Inverse Cases, Eminent Domain and Land Valuation Litigation, ALI-CLE, January 23, 2020
  • Improving Actions Leading Up to the 40-day Offer and Prior to Filing of a Complaint, IRWA Fall Education Event, October 16, 2019
  • The “Three Unities” – Still a Problem? A Discussion of Larger Parcel Issues, Oregon Eminent Domain Conference, The Seminar Group, June 6, 2019
  • Preparing Appraisals for Condemnation Assignments and How to Improve Skills as an Expert Witness, Appraisal Institute – Greater Oregon Chapter, January 20, 2017
  • Overview of the Condemnation Process, 8th Annual Oregon Eminent Domain Conference, The Seminar Group, June 5, 2015
  • Ejectment; Suits to Quiet Title, Chapter 61, Oregon Real Estate Deskbook, June, 2015
  • Collateral Damage from Newberg-Dundee Bypass Project, Daily Journal of Commerce, December 19, 2013
  • Columbia River Crossing Will Impact 200 Properties, Portland Business Journal, November 12, 2012]
  • Portland-Milwaukie Light Rail “Mega Project” Moves Forward, Daily Journal of Commerce, April 26, 2011

Reported Case

  • Tri-County Metropolitan Transportation District of Oregon v. Walnut Hill, LLC, 292 Or. App. 417, 424 P.3d 742 (2018) (eminent domain; TriMet light-rail condemnation; jury verdict for just compensation and attorney fees affirmed).

Notable Oregon Property Rights Cases of OCA Emeritus Member Jill S. Gelineau

U.S. Supreme Court

  • Dolan v. City of Tigard, 512 U.S. 374 (1994), on remand, 319 Or 567, 877 P2d 1201 (1994). Landmark exactions case establishing the “rough proportionality” test for permit conditions. (Represented the Dolan family on remand)

Oregon Supreme Court

  • Hope Presbyterian Church of Rogue River v. Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), 352 Or 668, 291 P3d 711 (2012). Dispute over church real property and trust ownership. (Amicus Curiae for the Presbyterian Lay Committee)
  • West Linn Corporate Park, L.L.C. v. City of West Linn, No. S056322 (2010). Certified question on interest owed on just compensation in the condemnation of corporate park property. (Co-counsel with D. Joe Willis)

Oregon Court of Appeals

  • Proctor v. City of Portland, 245 Or App 378, 263 P3d 1099 (2011). Challenge to Portland’s business license tax as applied to real estate broker-agents.
  • Clear Channel Outdoor, Inc. v. City of Portland, 231 Or App 511, 220 P3d 100 (2011). Constitutional challenge to Portland’s sign code regulations.
  • Hammer v. City of Eugene, No. A122564 (2005). (Represented the respondent property owner)

Property Rights in the State of Oregon

Oregon’s private property right protections are fairly strong, but still fall short of full protection of property owners. After the United States Supreme Court’s decision in Kelo (holding that private redevelopment plans were a permissible “public use”), Oregon voters passed a ballot measure that tried to shift the balance back toward protecting private property owners from eminent domain abuse. That measure prohibited the condemnation of property where the condemning agency intends to convey all or part of the acquired property to a private third party. In addition, the measure revised the eligibility for reimbursement of attorney and expert fees and costs, requiring the property owner to merely beat the condemnor’s pre-filing offer to be entitled to reimbursement (instead of the previous requirement that the property owner was required to beat an offer made by the agency just 30 days prior to trial, giving the condemnor an unfair advantage because the owner would have already shared any appraisals it intended to rely upon at trial).

A SUMMARY OF OREGON'S EMINENT DOMAIN LAWS

The following responses are intended to provide general information about eminent domain laws in the featured state. Such information does not constitute legal advice. Anyone interested in learning more about eminent domain law and the impact it may have on a given set of facts should consult with an OCA attorney or another attorney experienced in handling eminent domain cases.

  • Who Can Exercise Eminent Domain Laws?

    An agency or entity can only take private land for public use when the Oregon legislature specifically grants the authority to do so. Bridal Veil Lumbering Co. v. Johnson, 30 Or. 205, 208, 46 P. 790 (1896); GTE NW, Inc. v. Pub. Util. Comm’n of Oregon, 320 Or. 458, 466, 900 P.2d 495 (1995), cert. denied, 517 U.S. 1155 (1996). Many public bodies, quasi-public bodies, and private corporations have been granted authority to exercise eminent domain through statutes and home-rule charter, including the state and its various state agencies and departments, cities, counties, municipalities, port authorities, irrigation districts, railroads and railway companies, electric companies, gas companies, school districts, community college districts, transit districts, metropolitan service districts, people’s utility districts, pipeline companies, sanitary districts and authorities, water control districts, drainage districts and authorities, water control companies, service districts, and utility cooperatives.

    The authority to condemn is typically found in the statutes related to the particular agency or company type rather than in Oregon’s eminent domain code (Oregon’s eminent domain code, found in ORS Chapter 35, instead sets forth the procedures for condemning property). Because a public or private entity may only condemn if that authority has been specifically delegated to it by the Oregon legislature, a property owner whose land is being condemned should confirm such delegation at the outset of any condemnation case to determine whether the agency or entity attempting to exercise eminent domain powers actually has the lawful authority to do so.

  • What Are the Legal Requirements for Exercising the Power?

    Under Oregon law, private property can only be condemned for the public use and benefit, and cannot be condemned if the condemnor intends to convey all or part of the property to a private third party. In any condemnation, just compensation must be paid for all property taken. Procedurally, Oregon requires condemnors to appraise the property and to make a formal offer to the property owner to purchase the property. This offer is typically accompanied by the condemnor’s appraisal. The condemnor must then allow the property owner at least 40 days to consider the offer prior to filing condemnation proceedings.

    To learn more about the procedural aspects of eminent domain cases in Oregon, look to Chapter 35 of the Oregon Revised Statutes.

  • What Limitations or Defenses Exist?

    The grounds for challenging the right to condemn are quite limited under Oregon law. The condemning authority will typically make a formal finding that its project is a public use and that the particular properties to be acquired are necessary for the project. That finding is given significant deference by Oregon courts. Occasionally, defenses can be raised as to (a) whether a proper public use exists for the condemnation, (b) whether the prerequisite legal authority is present, or (c) whether required procedural steps were taken. If a challenge can be brought, the Court will review the submitted evidence and rule on the defenses in a proceeding prior to the trial to determine just compensation.

    As noted, deference is typically given to a condemnor’s decision to condemn, unless the agency has committed fraud, acted in bad faith, or has abused its discretion. In the absence of fraud, bad faith, or the abuse of discretion, the Court will presume that a condemnor’s ordinance or resolution establishes the public necessity of the proposed use; the property is necessary for the project; and that the proposed use, improvement, or project is planned and located in a manner that is the “most compatible with the greatest public good and the least private injury.” ORS 35.235(2).

  • What Constitutes a Public Purpose?

    Like the United States Constitution, Oregon’s Constitution limits the use of eminent domain to projects that constitute a “public use.” Oregon courts have defined “public use” broadly to include any use affecting the general public (even if the use is only be a small part of a community) rather than benefiting particular individuals. Public uses generally include highways, roads, parks, schools, and other improvements that serve the public benefit.

    As discussed above, following the United States Supreme Court’s decision in Kelo, Oregon voters passed a ballot measure that prohibited the government from condemning property of one private property owner on behalf of another private property owner (a common approach to economic redevelopment). However, the uses for which an agency can condemn property are still very broad, and may include some economic development projects. If a property owner’s property is being condemned for economic development, the question of public purpose deserves close and careful analysis.

  • How is Just Compensation Determined?

    The major focus of most eminent domain cases is in Oregon is obtaining just compensation for the property owner. Just compensation includes the fair market value of the property taken (or the fair market value of that which the owner has been deprived of by reason of the acquisition of the owner’s property). When an entire parcel of property is taken, just compensation is the fair market value of the parcel plus any improvements (to the extent the improvements enhance the value of the land). See State by and through State Highway Comm’n v. Superbilt Mfg. Co., 204 Or. 393, 412, 281 P.2d 707 (1955); State by and through State Highway Comm’n v. Anderson, 234 Or. 328, 331, 381 P.2d 707 (1963). For partial takings, just compensation includes both the value of the portion of the property condemned and any reduction in the fair market value of the owner’s remaining property caused by the taking. See State by and through Dep’t of Transp. v. Lundberg, 312 Or. 568, 574, 825 P.2d 641, cert. denied, 506 U.S. 975 (1992); State by and through State Highway Comm’n v. Hooper, 259 Or. 555, 560, 488 P.2d 421 (1971).

    Just compensation also requires that the property be valued at its highest and best use, which is not always the current use of the property. See Lundberg and Superbilt, supra. If just compensation cannot be agreed to by the condemnor and the owner, it will be determined at trial by a jury.

  • How Is Fair Market Value Defined?

    In Oregon, “[f]air market value is defined as the amount of money the property would bring if it were offered for sale by one who desire, but was not obliged, to sell and was purchased by one who was willing, but not obliged, to buy.” State by and through Dep’t of Transp. v. Lundberg, 312 Or. 538, 574, 825 P.2d 641, cert. denied, 506 U.S. 975 (1992). Fair market value is determined by considering all factors “that might fairly be brought forward and reasonably be given substantial weight in negotiations between the owner and a prospective purchaser.” State by and through State Highway Comm’n v. Superbilt Mfg. Co., 204 Or. 393, 412, 281 P.2d 707 (1955).

    The date the property is valued is either the date the condemnation complaint is filed or the date that the condemnor takes possession of the property, whichever is earlier. Because fair market value is often driven by both the date of value applied and the highest and best use of the property, both elements play an important role and impact the fair market value determination. Generally, the property’s fair market value is the subject of opinion testimony by expert qualified real estate appraisers, although a non-corporate owner is typically allowed to testify as to the value of the property being taken. Appraisers can use a combination of different valuation approaches to determine the fair market value of the property, including comparable sales, income, and cost approaches.

  • What About Recovering Damages to Remaining Property?

    When a condemnor takes only a portion of the property (or less than the fee interest), just compensation will be paid both for the property actually taken and for the reduction in the fair market value of the owner’s remaining property caused by the taking. This is known as severance damage. However, property owners should understand that other common damages are not compensable, including (a) government activities that are considered a use of the government’s police power (e.g., regulating traffic lanes and speed, parking regulations, access restrictions, and changes in the highway system resulting in reduced or increased volume of traffic), (b) business losses or lost profits resulting from interference, interruption, or restriction in the operation of the business, (c) temporary inconvenience during construction of a public project, (d) remote or speculative damages, and (e) consequential damages related to a public project where no taking of the owner’s land actually occurs. Note, however, that a property owner who must move from their property as a direct result of the project may be able to recover some of its costs associated with moving, under an agency’s relocation assistance program.

  • Is the Landowner Entitled to Recover Reasonable Attorney Fees? Expert Fees? Litigation Costs?

    In Oregon, an owner is often able to recover its cost and expenses, including appraisal costs and expert fees incurred in preparing and conducting the defense of a condemnation action. ORS 35.335. In addition, in many circumstances, the owner can be reimbursed for its reasonable attorney fees. ORS 35.346(7). By statute, the property owner will be reimbursed for its reasonable attorney fees when: (1) the amount of the final just compensation determined by the court or jury exceeds the highest written offer submitted by the condemnor to the owner prior to filing the condemnation action; (2) the court determines that the first written offer made to the owner prior to the condemnation action was not a good-faith offer of an amount reasonably believed by the condemnor to be just compensation; or (3) the condemnor abandons the condemnation action once filed but prior to final adjudication, the action is dismissed or terminated, or the condemnor elects to not take the property up to 60 days after the verdict. ORS 35.346(7) and ORS 35.335.

REFERENCES AND LINKS

Get the Latest Insights

Subscribe for Blog Updates!

close
email telephone877-367-6963